Some folks might think posting here is all fun and games. Not for me. I often second guess myself and regret hitting the "Post!" button:
• Publicly expressing such harsh criticism, bordering on vitriolic, couldn't be further from my nature.
• It's not about me even though I often write about myself and my experiences in the cult.
• My tendency to exaggerate ever so slightly at times requires vigilance to keep things within the bounds of accuracy and proportionality.
• I'm in no position to judge others. Yet, as necessary as it is to separate the words and actions of premies under the influence of Prem Rawat, typically in defense of him, from his grip on them, sometimes their words and actions scream for it.
• Then there's this tiny little issue of being among the +/- .02%* of former followers who've spoken out publicly against Prem Rawat in the face of all the practicing premies, dignitaries and other officials who've honored Prem in various ways, and administrators who've invited PEP into their institutions, etc. ... all over the world.
Given those and other parameters, limitations and guardrails, I suppose second guessing myself is a healthy sign of sanity and still being tethered to my conscience and moral compass. My point in mentioning all this is that I almost didn't make that reply to Lesley. What tipped the scale was the thought that what I say doesn't matter anyway. What matters is that it might serve as a catalyst for a remarkable or even an extraordinary reply, which both you and Lesley came through with.
"There doesn't seem to be much mystery about how and why we walked into a cult and got stuck there. Our naivety looking back is very plain to see. All we knew is what we knew so far, and it wasn't enough to look at it all with sufficient critical distance."
After all these years and except for your recent posts, I've seldom heard it spelled-out so neatly.
"We were thinking with soup for brains... It's more amazing that we got out of the cult than we fell in. Like a fish going, wait, what is this stuff I'm swimming in?"
I can hear the lurkers shouting "Water is where fish belong!" as they equate it with and embrace their all-encompassing "connection" to Prem Rawat and Knowledge, which only reinforces your perfect analogy.
Then you ended with "... like Aunt Bea, I'm not convinced any of us really have any free will anyway. More like balls in a pinball machine, but with some ability to reflect on what just happened."
As I contemplate this, I'm keenly aware that as things happen, the vast majority of the time I react as instantaneously, instinctively and even involuntarily as Daniel Kahneman pointed out in his book. Absolutely no time to pause, reflect and exercise what might be viewed as premeditated free will... much like balls in a pinball machine. To live otherwise would be like living in a frozen state of paralysis and might even get you committed. Even premeditated actions are governed by unpredictable reactions, reactions to reactions and ever changing circumstances out of our control. Multiply that by everything and it's a bit disconcerting that what you suggest may very well be true!
• timing and circumstances of birth and death
• inability to see or predict the future
• unanticipated consequences leading to unanticipated consequences
• onset of disease
• good luck versus bad luck if there's any such thing as luck
The arguments against free will are profound and I'm sure there are authors (in recent posts) who spell it out in compelling ways. Uncertainty, fear, anxiety and vulnerability are fodder for charlatans like Prem. And speaking of lurkers, don't give me that "conscious" crap. I can't stand that word in the context of this cult... the miasma of some lofty, smug, condescending and superior pretense that does nothing but invisibly separate people. Did I mention it's crap?
I wanted to joke about "soup for brains," not only because it sounds funny, but also because that's not the way I've heard it expressed. Then it occurred to me that soup is another perfect analogy because it's an amalgamation of necessary and essential ingredients whereas the other is not.
I hope your daughter gets her Ph. D. Family get-togethers must be extra-special for you.

* Very loosely calculated as perhaps 200 former followers who've spoken out publicly over the years on various platforms, out of perhaps 1,000,000 premies and advocates, including India. I would gladly defer to Prembio or anyone else.